Skip to Content
Logo
Menu
  • About Our Firm
  • Practice Areas
  • Our People
  • Learning Library
  • Corporate Transparency Act
  • Contact
  • Make A Payment

Negligent Hiring Remains a Narrowly Construed Tort In Illinois

Negligent Hiring Remains a Narrowly Construed Tort In Illinois

January 28, 2019

A recent opinion by Illinois’ Second District Court of Appeals reaffirmed that the tort of negligent hiring will be narrowly construed in certain instances. So narrowly construed, in fact, that an employee may be denied a trial and the employer will be granted summary judgment.

The Facts in the Brettman Case

The case in Brettman arose from a traffic accident between Gina Brettman and a tractor trailer driven by Isreal Vela, an employee of E.G.G. Trucking. The driver, Mr. Vela, was contracted with by M&G, a Texas company that brokers freight delivery. M&G hired E.G.G. to transport a load of pickles from a Texas pickle plant to Huntley. After the load of pickles was delivered, and Mr. Vela was on his way to his next assignment, he ran a red light and hit Ms. Brettman’s automobile causing her severe injuries.

Even though Mr. Vela was an independent contractor for M&G, Ms. Brettman and her Guardian sued M&G on a theory of negligent hiring and retention. Ms. Brettman alleged that if M&G had done an adequate investigation of Mr. Vela and E.G.G., it would have discovered that E.G.G. was an unrated motor carrier and Mr. Vela had a history of forging his timesheets.

Look to Proximate Cause Not Legal Duty Says the Court of Appeals

Illinois’ Second District Court of Appeals declined to analyze whether M&G should have done a better job with its background check. It also declined to second guess whether M&G should have chosen a better trucking company or a driver less inclined to forgery. Instead, the Court held that as a matter of law M&G could not be found to have proximately caused Ms. Brettman’s injuries because she was injured after the load of pickles had been delivered. It is unusual for a court to decide proximate cause issues as a matter of law without submitting them to a jury.

The Court said the relevant inquiry in negligent hiring or retention cases should focus on the work to be performed and whether the incompetent execution of that work caused harm to a third party. Since the delivery of the pickles was completed, the work that M&G contracted with Mr. Vela was completed. His subsequent accident with Ms. Brettman could not have been caused by M&G as a matter of law.

Employer Takeaways from Brettman

1. No Liability for Posttermintation Acts

The Brettman decision tells us that even when an employee or independent contractor makes a mistake and hurts a third party, the defense team should review when the accident or negligence occurred. Illinois courts will not find employers liable for negligent hiring or retention if the accident or injury occurs after the completion of the contracted-for-work.

2. May Be Liability for Out-of-Scope Acts

Brettman also affirms that an employer may be liable for out-of-the-scope acts by its employees, but only where the employee is on the employer’s premises or using the chattel of the employer and the employer has reason to know of the need and opportunity for exercising control over the employee. A fuller discussion of this scenario is set forth in a case against the Boy Scouts.

3. Employers Must Still Be Careful Choosing Their Independent Contractors

Finally, even though an employer may be exonerated on summary judgment, Brettman is a reminder that plaintiffs will sue employers regardless of whether the wrong doer is an employee or an independent contractor. So keep doing those background checks, and hire with care.

Related Attorneys

Clingen Callow & McLean, LLC
Lisle Office
2300 Cabot Drive, Suite 500
Lisle, Illinois, 60532
Phone 630.871.2600
Geneva Office
21 North 4th Street
Geneva, Illinois, 60134
Phone 630.938.4769
Fax 630.871.9869
General Inquires [email protected]
  • facebook
  • linkedin

Contact Us

©2025 Clingen Callow & McLean, LLC. All rights reserved.

Law Firm Web Design by NMC

Manage Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}